Building Cryptographic Agility in the Financial Sector
Understand the elements, processes, and challenges of cryptographic agility
Executive Summary
The concept of cryptographic agility has been known for at least two decades. The FS-ISAC Post-Quantum Cryptography Working Group’s definition is:
Crypto Agility is a measure of an organization’s ability to adapt cryptographic solutions or algorithms (including their parameters and keys) quickly and efficiently in response to developments in cryptanalysis, emerging threats, technological advances, and/or vulnerabilities.
It is also a design principle for implementing, updating, replacing, running, and adapting cryptography and related business processes and policy with no significant architectural changes, minimal disruption to business operations, and short transition time.
The goal of cryptographic agility – or crypto agility – is simple: to enable business continuity if/when existing cryptography is compromised or weakened.
The move to crypto agility must begin immediately because quantum computing is likely to make a commonly used class of cryptography algorithms insecure in the next few years. The financial services sector cannot risk insecure data transmission or storage – it would break the way we conduct business today. And as the number of systems, dependencies between systems, and overall technical complexity grow, the effort to update cryptographic assets has intensified.
The sector has been through several cryptographic transitions in the past and each was more complex and time consuming than the last. It is an endless cycle and becoming unsustainable. By becoming crypto agile, practitioners will be able to quickly replace cryptographic algorithms using a repeatable process with minimal impact or downtime and provide sufficient confidentiality, integrity, and/or non-repudiation guarantees. Importantly, firms will avoid the vulnerabilities of insecure algorithms.
This paper, written by the FS-ISAC Post-Quantum Cryptography Working Group (PQC Working Group), explains the process in detail and provides guidance and advice to financial services firms – or those of any industry – to help them become crypto agile. The document provides these key concepts:
- A framework for implementing crypto agility
- Challenges and how to overcome them
- Insights on transition governance and architecture
We leverage and expand on crypto agility concepts coined at Google, IBM, Hochschule Darmstadt and others and provide new information as well. As such, this is the first comprehensive document to detail precisely what is needed to implement crypto agility in financial services institutions.
The FS-ISAC PQC Working Group produced this document to help financial institutions prepare for a post-quantum world. Our intention is to help the sector manage change for the next likely transitions in information security. The sector must demonstrate to our customers, boards, and regulators that we’re taking the challenge head on, working together, and preparing for the long term. Embracing crypto agility is a necessary element of that.